Curate, connect, and discover
Okay this is what I’m talking about with my girl Louise. She only would have had one chance to give up her tail, but that was 50 years ago when Gracie gave hers up, and as we saw from that scene, and based on the fact that Louise and Julia both kept their lockets as reminders of what once was/the truth of what they are, both Julia and Louise were mermaids up until the end. As a kid I remembered her losing her tail/simply not having it anymore, but whenever I rewatch I love the subtle, unspoken detail that she never once touches water. Yes, she’s more comfortable being near water, but one of the first times she’s introduced she’s holding her hand just above the water at the Marine Park, insinuating that she still can’t get wet, and that she’s still very much so a mermaid.
this is why i always believe ms chatham got her tail back bc to believe anything else is too depressing