Gianlorenzo Bernini, 1619 Sleeping Hermaphroditos Details

Gianlorenzo Bernini, 1619 Sleeping Hermaphroditos details

Winter 2018 Anime Watchlist

Wow, this is almost inexcusably late Dx I’m so sorry, this should’ve gone up last week. It took me so long because I was waiting for Fate/Extra -which premiered three weeks into the season for inexplicable reasons- and then other stuff came up during the week. The good side is that it’s allowed me to get a better grasp on what these shows are doing and rank them more accordingly to my expectations rather than just the first impressions (except Fate Extra because I’ve only watched one episode -_-. Anyway, here’s the list for the Winter shows I’m watching

Dropped

Pop Team Epic: Not my kind of comedy. Honestly that’s all there is to this show, whether it’s type of comedy (or anti-comedy) works for you. It didn’t extract a single chuckle from me, so no point in watching more of it.

KOKKOKU: The premise is interesting, the interactions between the family members felt very human and realistic and the main character was pretty cool, but the look of the show is terrible and the pacing is stressfully slow. At the end of episode 2, the nephew and the brother hadn’t been rescued yet -and there seemed to be no hurry in that regard- and that just made gratuitously anxious

Sora Yori Tooi Basho: I think that this show, like Girls’ Last Tour, has a lot of potential, but I’ve been burned before and with the pacing of episode two I just had this nagging feeling that the show would manage to flounder around all season without the girls ever making it to Antarctica, which would be a bummer. So I’ll wait for the season to end, and if they do end up getting there I’ll pick it up again.

Citrus: Citrus leaves me in a complicated position because Yuzu is a very charming lead and it’s very easy to root for her, I strongly feel that I want to follow her story. But on the other hand, her love interest / stepsister (thanks Japan) is utterly unlikable, and so far every “romantic” advancement in the story is basically sexual assault. It’s odd because Yuzu herself feels realistic, but the development of the romance is immensely artificial. By the end of episode 2, Yuzu declares she’s inequivocally in love with her sister (idr her name), even though none of the events of the show to that point make her quick infatuation believable at all, considering the sister in question only insults her, dismisses her or sexually assaults her every time they interact. (Update: After episode 4 I want nothing to do with the Everyone is a Lesbian and All Lesbians are Rapists show)

Chopping Block

Basically, I’m gonna drop one or more of this shows sooner than later. I’m still not sure of which one

Darling in the FRANXX: If you thought Welcome to the Ballroom was aggressively heterosexual, DarliFra wants you to hold its beer. Episode 1 was a little iffy with its eyeroll inducing cliché meet-cute between the two leads, itsheteronormative central conceit (a man-woman pair is necessary to operate the giant robots and they take on roles named after the reproductive parts of flowers), but if that wasn’t enough for you, episode 2 is 24 minutes of cheap juvenile innuendos at least 70% of the dialogues have very obvious, very intentional double-meanings- coupled with extremely unsubtle “hyuk hyuk they are totally not in a sexual position” imagery, plus an infinite numer of ass shots (only of the girls, obviously). The whole thing reeks of sleazy, hipocritically critical of the dystopian society it depicts whilst simultaneously objectifying and sexualizing its adolescent leads with the most bottom of the barrel, lowest common denominator possible jokes and framing. Depending on how episode 3 goes I’ll either drop it or choose it as my hatewatch show of the season. (Update: Episode 3 was a mixed bag, so I guess I’ll keep watching for now)

Basilisk Ouka Ninpou Chou: We’re three episodes in and it doesn’t feel like this story is going anywhere. The production values are terrible, and the initial conceit -that Oboro and Gennosuke had time to make babies at some point during the original Basilisk series- makes literally no sense whatsoever. I’m a huge fan of the original Basilisk, but this is giving me nothing so far. Honestly the only thing keeping me around is how close the designs are to the original, basically the character designers are invoking my fondness for the original series and cheating me into believing I like this one too. Which I don’t, but for the time being I’ll hang on.

Violet Evergarden: I’m having war flashbacks to the Summer of 2017 when all the shows I was most excited about turned out to be hugely disappointing. Violet isn’t “hugely disappointing” yet but it’s very… eh. Violet herself (or, in the incredibly wise words of @shaniajurgen , “Full Metal Saber”) is just incredibly unrelatable and unoriginal as a character. I’ve seen this exact same story (emotionally stunted lead learns about human emotions) at least a dozen times, and the stories we’re seeing here so far are following the same plot beats as other stories of the ssame kind. The production itself is beautiful, but Violet feels more like a kuudere waifu than an actual character. I’m hoping it will improve and that it’ll have stories I haven’t already seen 10 times before, and that the emotional payoff is worth it

Koi wa Ameagari no you ni: This is a complicated show to talk about because the subject matter is inherently iffy -a 17 year old girl falls in love with a 45 year old man- The opening also pretty much gives away that they will in one way or another pursue a romantic relationship, so no hopes of this turning into a heartwarming parental dynamic like Amaama to Inazuma . It is important to note that writing fictional stories with fictional characters about this subject matter is not in itself problematic, but the framing of it can absolutely be malicious. Thus, if someone feels uncomfortable about it, that doesn’t make them a prude, but at the same time, enjoying the show doesn’t make you a pedophile. Bottomline is that the framing will make or break the show, and so far, it’s treading a very delicate line in that regard. On one hand, both Akira and Kondo are treated as realistic human characters; on the other, there are certain aspects of the narrative that seem to play up to the ‘nice guy’ mentality -she was throwing herself at me! I’m completely harmless!-. It’s not heavyhanded enough to be off-putting, but it does make me feel cautious about where they’re going with this. (Update: Episode 4 was definitely off-putting, enough to make me consider dropping it.)

??????

Stuff I’m watching that I’m not super passionate about I guess

Fate/Extra Last Encore: Well, this sure is a SHAFT show. Of course, Extra has a disadvantage against the other shows, having aired one episode vs the others’ 3-4, so for now I’ll keep it on a trial run. It’s bizarre and overly criptic and please don’t cut yourself on that edge son. I’m also not a fan of bringing back the original Fate cast, just replacing the original Palurdo with a different Wake ME Up INSIDE Palurdo. Apocrypha was decent because it avoided most pseudo philosophical Nasu bullshit, but they’re doubling down on that here, so that could be a problem. We’ll have to see how they handle the action scenes and whether they’re able to create compelling character dynamics

How to keep a Mummy: It’s a cute show. An aggressively cute show. Occassionally too triehard in its cuteness. If you’re into cute shows this is for you, if not, there’s really nothing to chew on. I hope we get the new monsters soon or some sort of character arc, much as I enjoy the cuteness, I do need a little bit more meat in my Chinese cartoons

Classicaloid: My feelings on Classicaloid vary wildly depending on the last episode I watched, and in this case, the latest episode wasn’t really good. I loved the part with Beethoven being blown away by the performance of the 9th, but otherwise the jokes felt like cheap potty humor. You can do much better Classicaloid

Hakumei to Mikochi: So, rather than a fantasy adventure, this is actually a fantasy slce of life. Which is fine in itself, but in a season that has a dozen feel-good slice of life stuff, it needs an extra punch to stand out. The characters are good and fun to watch and the stories are cute, the visuals have a lovely children’s book look, but there’s not much that is particularly memorable. But it’s cute and there are worse shows I’m watching, so I’ll keep it around.

Hakata Tonkotsu Ramens: This is a weird show because I slept through most of episodes 1 and 2 but the final cliffhanger of each episode made eager to keep watching. After episode 4, I’m definitely interested in seeing where they go with this premise. The dynamic between Lin and Banba is great and although the direction and production are mostly uninspired, the story seems interesting enough to grant some attention

Finally some good stuff

My favorite stuff of the season and the only thing keeping me from launching myself into the sun given how sucky my classes this semester are

GARO Vanishing Line: The plot thickens as our heroes approach the mysterious El Dorado. Now that we’ve had a Gina-centric and a Sword-centric episode the cast feels well rounded and their deynamics have evolved in a really wonderful way. I definitely love the family-like relationship they have now, with the latest episode shedding some light on how Sword may be seeing her sister in Sophie. I’m really happy with how this show has developed since its early episodes.

Yowamushi Pedal Glory Line: There’s not much I can say about Yowapeda at this point, you either like to see 3 kilometers of a bicycle race stretched into an hour of television or you don’t. I do find it interesting that Onoda seems to have fallen completely to the sidelines, hardly appearing in the first four episodes. I also wonder how long this’ll be because we’re 4 episodes in in and we haven’t been able to finish the first day of the race, even though we started like 3km off of it, so unless this is two-cour I worry we won’t see the end of the Inter High.

Seven Deadly Sins: Revival of the Commandments: I’m quite ahead of the manga for this one so there are hardly any surprises here. I think implementing the numerical power levels was very stupid and I’m not sure what Suzuki was thinking when he decided to add it but w/e. Ban is my favorite character so ‘m enjoying these first episodes centered on him. I’m mostly excited to see Escanor though! And the choreography of the Diane vs Gowther fight was superb.

Sanrio Danshi: I must admit this show has fallen a little from my good graces in the recent episodes. Episode 2 was brilliant and it made me think maybe this show could be better written than your average toy commercial. And although it is, episodes 3 and 4 haven’t lived up to the highs established by 2. Instead of just focusing on the issues the boys face from liking Sanrio things, they’ve overcomplicated the conflicts, making them incomprehensible, and the resolutions feel rushed here’s hoping we have more episodes like 2.

Gakuen Babysitters: The surprise of the season! Although it stumbled a little in the first half of episode 3, this overall wins for the cutest show of the season, and the one with most heart. It’s struck an excellet balance showing the chiildren’s cutest and also most obnoxious sides too. The end of episode 1 in which Ryuuichi realizes he can’t call his parents for help was extremely well executed, striking at the heartstrings with a very realistic and human approach to tragedy. Also, I love Kirin and her kirin plushie. Hope we get a Kirin centric episode soon. Just delete the “pedo” character please.

Mahoutsukai no Yome: My thoughts on this show are about the same as last season, it’s a lovely story with extremely powerful moments that is occassionally brought down by weird pacing choices, like how they rushed Chise’s transformation into a fox. I do have to call the show out for the OP, it’s the laziest thing I’ve ever seen, completely made up of recycled shots from the first cour. As much as I love May’n, the song falls short to the power JUNNA’s Here had. If they weren’t gonna add anything to the OP that was relevant to the second cour they should’ve just kept the first one.

Card Captor Sakura: Clear Card: I am so happy and so relieved to see Sakura has escaped the curse of “20 year later reboot” that befell on other classics. They nailed the feel of the show to a tee, and I’m just overall so happy to get to see the characters I so love once again. I am concerned about the repetitive plot beats and about the original cards getting seemingly forgotten, but I’m confident in this team that has proved to make justice for such a beloved show.

That’s the winter season, a few standouts, a few great surprises, a lot of stuff that is just kinda there and a shitload of slice of life. What are you thinking about the season? Which are your favorite shows and which ones have you dropped so far?

1K notes View Post