I’ve Seen An Awful Lot Of Posts Re: The New Murtagh Book About How “unfair” Eragon And Nasuada

I’ve seen an awful lot of posts re: the new Murtagh book about how “unfair” Eragon and Nasuada were to Murtagh by railing at him and telling him to turn on Galbatorix in Inheritance. And I find that so shocking? what were they supposed to be doing, whispering “it’s ok sweetie, do your best alright we luv you :) uwu take your time honey”?? Dude has had his will broken and his mind enslaved by an evil mastermind, he’s full of rage and angst– shouldn’t they be trying to bring those emotions to the surface to help him break free? Also, Murtagh is not the kind of character that enjoys a pity party or is even vaguely comfortable with being vulnerable around others, including those he loves (on many levels), as a result of all those years of abuse and torture. I doubt it would’ve felt very compelling to him if his companions stayed silent or just offered platitudes and hollow encouragements– what should they have said, you got this, bro”?

Idk, I think that it’s interesting that as a fandom we can spend a lot of mental energy (and I mean a lot, 20 years of it over here on my end!!) bending over backwards being compassionate towards Broody McWarcrimes because he has been mind controlled and tortured within an inch of his life, but Goodboy Mainkid and Badass Queenieface try to get him out of his broody dark spiral of a brain for once and it’s like “oh my god, they’re so manipulative, they don’t even care”. Eragon had seen and done Some Shit and Nasuada was also a tortured mind control prisoner (by this guy!!), but for not being moody emo kids about their pain, the way Murtagh is, and compartmentalizing it differently than he does (too stoically, possibly), it’s like it erases their suffering for some people, and I think that’s an unfortunate reaction. If your traumatized friend was maybe the key to saving all your lives, wouldn’t you try to snap them out of their misery in any way you could, magic or no magic? Paolini says it himself multiple times in the new book - “Murtagh was feeling bad for himself again”. It’s the way a lot of us would cope with severely traumatic shit, I’m sure, brood and overthink and marinate in our pain. That doesn’t mean it’s compelling behavior for the people who are depending on you. I think Murtagh needed that needling, that boost from Nasuada and Eragon to get the ball rolling, or else he would not have been clear-headed enough to really think about his true name changing, because he would still have been stuck in the dark, sad spiral of the mind control, and it might have taken more time than they really had for him to get right with himself. They’re not chiding him and making light of his plight, they’re reminding him that he is even stronger than he knows and that they believe in him.

I love that little emo-boy blorbo, but he broods too much, and I think it’s ok for them to say it!

More Posts from Whitelightningoverasunset and Others

When The Writers Block So Bad You Gotta Draw The Fic Instead

when the writers block so bad you gotta draw the fic instead

actual conversation i had with my friends today

me: omg you remember that fic i was reading that i talked to you about slow burn that was like 16 chapters in and person A hadn’t even show romantic interest in person B yet 

PERSON A JUST GOT JEALOUS OF PERSON B OMG IT’S FUCKING HAPPENING

friend: yayyy 

me: OMG THEY ARE TOUCHING EACH OTHER HANDS

OMGGGGGG PERSON A JUST KISSED PERSON B HAND OMG I FEEL LIKE I’M READING SMUT

and that’s what slow burn fics do to me

have y’all ever thought how fucking grand and iconic it would be , if guardian was actually gay ? like , the show itself , you know .

there are so many aspects to it that would be no joke groundbreaking . and i’m not even talking about a chinese show being gay . like , have you ever thought about how much weilan’s story defies homophobic stereotypes ?

for starters , guardian is a sci-fi show with two queer main characters , which - correct me if i’m wrong - has never happened anywhere before . it also has a plot that fully depends on the love story of said two characters , though at the same time that plot is not entirely just about the two characters being gay without any further explanation . it’s not stereotypical either . it’s an actually beautifully thought-out love story .

another thing that a lot of homophobes love to push is that gay people can’t be in love / one person can’t be in love with another person of their gender . and i mean , what defies that better than a story about a man being in love with another man for ten thousand years , waiting for him and being faithful to him that entire time , despite not being able to see him ?

guardian is not just a bl , it’s not just a show that has absolutely zero plot and whose only saving grace is the fact that it is gay ( not that there is anything wrong with that tbh jfksjfksjfksjs ) . but , it is really a full blown sci-fi show with lots of different amazing characters , each of whom has their own plot .

it also doesn’t fall under the usual shitty plotline of either of the guys being confused about their feelings ? shen wei definitely isn’t , but neither is yun lan . he is absolutely sure in his love for shen wei , and when a girl chases after him and tells him she loves him - he rejects her without a shadow of a doubt . no way in hell would he want any woman , or anyone else really , when he has shen .

and why does no one talk about guardian punching toxic masculinity in the face ? shen wei is a man devoted to the love of his life for ten thousand entire years . yun lan is a man fully devoted both to a man he loves and also his team , which he also loves and cares for deeply ( and he shows it too , in many ways ) . guo changcheng is a fragile gentle boy , who doesn’t end up ‘ winning ‘ by becoming hyperly-masculine, but instead by embracing himself . and there is many more examples .

i can go on and on about this . guardian could do shit™️ if it was allowed to be what it was supposed to be from the very beginning . and i’m just so sad that it wasn’t .

A. The Way of Kings, The Titans Curse, Spirits End, The Crystal Shard, and Assassin's Apprentice. B. Tony Stark C. Captain America D. Zeref E. Brandon Sanderson F. Fantasy G. One Piece H. Tokyo Ghoul I. The Hobbit J. Good Omens K. ObiKaka L. Stucky M. Thriller O. Good Omens P. Embers Q. Paperback R. The Dark Artifices S. The Hobbit T. As is the Sea Marvelous, and I've Got You Deep in the Heart of Me U. Trafalgar D. Water Law V. Vinsmoke Sanji W. Neither X. Modern or Future Y. Yes. Z. The Eli Monpress series by Rachel Aaron, and anything with FitzChivalry Farseer by Robin Hobb.

📖Book asks📖

A. Top five favorite books?

B. Favorite character of all time?

C. Least favorite ‘good guy’?

D. Favorite villain?

E. Best author?

F. Si-Fi or fantasy?

G. The world you want to live in?

H. The world you love but would never live in?

I. Best book to movie adaption?

J. Movie that actually is better than the book?

K. Favorite ship?

L. Least favorite ship?

M. Romance or thriller?

O. Favorite old book?

P. Biggest book you’ve read?

Q. Paperback or hardcover?

R. Favorite trilogy?

S. Least favorite book?

T. Book/s that make you cry?

U. Biggest fictional crush?

V. Character you would spend a day with?

W. Harry Potter or twilight? Or neither?

X. Favorite time era for books?

Y. Would you ever write a book?

Z. Recommend?

every time I do a web search, right at the top I have AI info dumping on me

just give me the top result please

So I was recently rereading the Way of Kings, and in the middle of reading one of Kaladin’s flashbacks I had a thought. Deaged Kaladin. LIke they, (probably Navani), would be experimenting with Stormlight or a new fabrial or some new technology in Urithiru, and there’s an accident and suddenly there’s a teenage Kaladin who remembers nothing of the last 7 to 8 years. ‘Cause wouldn’t it be cool if Bridge Four, and Adolin, and Dalinar and all them could meet/interact with teen Kal. Because they would be shocked about how much different he is then compared to now. Like teen Kal has awe for lighteyes, and he hates to hurt people, and he’s torn between being a soldier or a surgeon. He believes in both, and he has to make a choice between them, and then in the middle of all his confusion, bam. He’s in a strange place with people he’s never seen before. If Dalinar or another like “warrior” lighteyes is there, cue the hero worship. Dalinar would want to adopt him on the spot. And Bridge Four would never let him out of their sight because their Captain is insane and always getting in trouble, and they expect the little Captain to be the EXACT SAME WAY. Teen Kal and Lift would be best friends, and she and Syl would enable him in his troublemaking ways, because he would absolutely go around and help all the people who are hurt that he can. And he would constantly be ditching Bridge 4 and Adolin, because you know Adolin would love and be fascinated with this Pure Child who actually likes lighteyes, because whenever Miny Captain leaves their sight he is GOING to get in trouble, and Lift and Syl enable it, because Lift is Lift and Syl finds it simultaneously sweet what Kaladin is doing, and Bridge 4′s attempts to stop him hilarious. 

Here’s another way of putting it since I’m all over the place with this.

Kaladin being deaged in Urithiru and the rest of them dying over this Pure Child. Some sort of accident happened to cause it. He and Lift become best friends. Bridge Four wants to protect this smol Pure Child, and basically stalk him. Or just blatantly never leave him alone. Because their Captain is reckless and insane about his own safety, and they don’t trust him by himself. Dalinar wants to adopt him but Bridge Four keeps thwartng him because the tiny Captain is theirs damn it! Adolin and Shallan love him and join Dalinar in fighting Bridge Four for the small Kal, Renarin is torn between enabling Adolin or Bridge Four. Eventually they set up a rotation over who gets to watch him. Kaladin finds medical supplies and then proceeds to run around all of Urithiru with Lift healing people. It drives everybody crazy. No one but Lift can keep up with him, and she enables him. Syl thinks it’s both sweet and hilarious, so helps Kal. Everyone who he helps loves him. 

Basically, it would be awesome and amazing for Kaladin to get deaged and for all of them to see how he used to be.


Tags
My (late) Contribution For Make A Terrible Comic Day! I've Been Going To The Library More Often Lately
My (late) Contribution For Make A Terrible Comic Day! I've Been Going To The Library More Often Lately
My (late) Contribution For Make A Terrible Comic Day! I've Been Going To The Library More Often Lately
My (late) Contribution For Make A Terrible Comic Day! I've Been Going To The Library More Often Lately
My (late) Contribution For Make A Terrible Comic Day! I've Been Going To The Library More Often Lately
My (late) Contribution For Make A Terrible Comic Day! I've Been Going To The Library More Often Lately
My (late) Contribution For Make A Terrible Comic Day! I've Been Going To The Library More Often Lately

My (late) contribution for Make A Terrible Comic Day! I've been going to the library more often lately so this has been coming up a lot, cause I want something to read but have had trouble finding anything that I'm comfortable with.

If anyone has recommendations please please let me know because I am struggling.

Noir Princesses By Ástor Alexander
Noir Princesses By Ástor Alexander
Noir Princesses By Ástor Alexander
Noir Princesses By Ástor Alexander
Noir Princesses By Ástor Alexander
Noir Princesses By Ástor Alexander
Noir Princesses By Ástor Alexander
Noir Princesses By Ástor Alexander
Noir Princesses By Ástor Alexander

Noir Princesses by Ástor Alexander

  • ninjawarriorprincess4
    ninjawarriorprincess4 reblogged this · 2 months ago
  • ninjawarriorprincess4
    ninjawarriorprincess4 liked this · 2 months ago
  • skynovakin
    skynovakin liked this · 3 months ago
  • anneeet
    anneeet liked this · 7 months ago
  • last-capy-hupping
    last-capy-hupping liked this · 8 months ago
  • andyyyyxo
    andyyyyxo liked this · 8 months ago
  • mitskiismyromanempire
    mitskiismyromanempire liked this · 9 months ago
  • steampunk-dragoncat
    steampunk-dragoncat liked this · 10 months ago
  • milfdarthrevan
    milfdarthrevan liked this · 10 months ago
  • nafisalivestowrite
    nafisalivestowrite liked this · 10 months ago
  • nsapphos
    nsapphos liked this · 10 months ago
  • middlingsister
    middlingsister liked this · 10 months ago
  • xenagzb
    xenagzb liked this · 11 months ago
  • plutoisarealplanet
    plutoisarealplanet liked this · 11 months ago
  • whitelightningoverasunset
    whitelightningoverasunset reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • whitelightningoverasunset
    whitelightningoverasunset liked this · 11 months ago
  • fatalfallacy
    fatalfallacy liked this · 11 months ago
  • reflectedmind23
    reflectedmind23 liked this · 11 months ago
  • misteriosamarilyn
    misteriosamarilyn liked this · 11 months ago
  • lvu2pcs
    lvu2pcs liked this · 11 months ago
  • aggressivelysoftblackgirl
    aggressivelysoftblackgirl liked this · 1 year ago
  • wingletblackbird
    wingletblackbird liked this · 1 year ago
  • larimarstar
    larimarstar liked this · 1 year ago
  • emmathedestroyer
    emmathedestroyer liked this · 1 year ago
  • whispers-into-the-void
    whispers-into-the-void liked this · 1 year ago
  • saintemiliosandoz
    saintemiliosandoz liked this · 1 year ago
  • charlie-leau
    charlie-leau liked this · 1 year ago
  • stripedblueoranges
    stripedblueoranges liked this · 1 year ago
  • wings-26
    wings-26 reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • wings-26
    wings-26 liked this · 1 year ago
  • euro-trashgirl
    euro-trashgirl liked this · 1 year ago
  • zafirosa
    zafirosa liked this · 1 year ago
  • a-metal-jelly-bean
    a-metal-jelly-bean liked this · 1 year ago
  • thilb0burrit0
    thilb0burrit0 liked this · 1 year ago
  • anegodesukana
    anegodesukana reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • marimo331
    marimo331 reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • marimo331
    marimo331 liked this · 1 year ago
  • nikitabono
    nikitabono liked this · 1 year ago
  • countdracublahh
    countdracublahh liked this · 1 year ago
  • nurse-nitemare
    nurse-nitemare liked this · 1 year ago
  • doloresabernathypiplup
    doloresabernathypiplup reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • 123goodmorning
    123goodmorning liked this · 1 year ago
  • abhorrenttester
    abhorrenttester reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • abhorrenttester
    abhorrenttester liked this · 1 year ago
  • garlicmashedpotatoes
    garlicmashedpotatoes liked this · 1 year ago
  • sahrasherrani
    sahrasherrani liked this · 1 year ago
  • forever-is-made-of-nows
    forever-is-made-of-nows liked this · 1 year ago

I identify as female with she/her pronouns. I love anything One Piece. Especially Trafalgar Law.

295 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags